• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Rakestraw's Ice Cream: Beloved Mechanicsburg Spot for Classic & Unique Flavors

Rakestraw’s Ice Cream in Mechanicsburg, PA, is more than just a dessert stop—it’s a cherished local tradition. With an inviting atmosphere and a wide array of flavors, including unique and no sugar added options, it offers something for every palate. The friendly staff make every visit warm and memorable, turning simple scoops into joyful experiences. Whether you’re escaping summer heat or creating family memories, Rakestraw’s delivers rich, creamy ice cream that feels like a sweet retreat. Though seating is limited, the quality and charm make it worth the visit, embodying the spirit of a beloved community gathering spot.

Rakestraw's Ice Cream at a glance

  • Address 313 S Market St, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055, United States
  • Phone +1 717-691-5353
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop , Dessert shop .
  • Popular for Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Rakestraw's Ice Cream: Reviews & Ratings

Drew Cremeans
5

My son and I set out with the noblest of intentions: exercise! On a blistering hot day, no less. We were nearing our turnaround point, feeling all virtuous, when BAM! Rakestraw's appeared like a mirage (a delicious, air-conditioned mirage). Our "good intentions" melted faster than a scoop on the asphalt, replaced by pure, unadulterated joy. This isn't just ice cream, folks; it's a divine intervention. And the staff? So friendly, they probably smiled as they watched our fitness goals evaporate. Seriously, better than most. Rakestraw's: saving souls (and taste buds) one scoop at a time.

Marcia H
5

I've been coming to Rakestraw’s since I was a kid growing up on Keller Street—it was a summer tradition I always looked forward to. Now, years later, it’s come full circle. Rakestraw’s has become a cherished part of life with my own family—my husband and our two children love it just as much as I always have. The new owners are doing a fantastic job, keeping the spirit of the place alive while making it better than ever. It’s more than just ice cream; it’s a place filled with sweet memories, old and new.

Salaadino
4

I came for their seasonal grand opening. It was crazy busy! The line was like 20 minutes long. But hey, the ice cream was great, lots of choices.

Trish Zenczak
4

This place sells Hershey’s ice cream and was pretty good. They had lots of unique flavors and had no sugar added flavors, too. The place is pretty large inside. The only reason for the 4 stars is they only have 6 chairs outside and no tables/chairs inside. There was plenty of room to add some seating. While we were there several families came and there was hardly room for all to sit. There is ample parking.

KIMBERLY PAUL
5

Delicious ice cream and the girls that served us were so sweet! We were given a punch card and will definitely return. It's very much worth it even though it's an hour and a half drive.

J Szczski
5

My favorite local ice cream place! Great service. Great ice cream. Excellent prices.

Fiona Mai
5

Some outdoor sitting and no indoor sitting - however. A lot of options to pick from, staff are friendly enough to let us sample. Will come back when in town. Also, have ice cream option for your fur baby. Plenty of parking in front of the store

woop17
5

Very creamy and delicious ice cream. The scoop portions are generous. I had the chocolate marshmallow and it had a great ratio of marshmallow to chocolate. Loved the classic look of the interior of the building.

Location

  • Rakestraw's Ice Cream
    Rakestraw's Ice Cream
    313 S Market St, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055, United States Hotline: +1 717-691-5353

Rakestraw's Ice Cream is a cherished gem nestled in Mechanicsburg, PA, known for turning simple summer visits into lasting family traditions. Walking into their spacious, air-conditioned parlor at 313 S Market St, you’re welcomed by a warm, friendly staff who serve up more than just ice cream—they serve moments of pure joy and nostalgia.

Their selection is impressively diverse, featuring classic Hershey’s ice cream alongside unique and no-sugar-added flavors, catering to all tastes and dietary preferences. Whether you find yourself combating the summer heat after a long walk or indulging in a well-earned treat, the scoops at Rakestraw’s melt away your worries and revive your spirit.

What truly stands out is the blend of tradition and care. Many loyal customers have grown up with Rakestraw’s, now bringing their own children to share in the sweet legacy, a testament to its heartfelt place in the community. The new ownership honors this heritage while elevating the experience with attentive service and quality offerings.

While the interior could benefit from more seating to match its generous parking and family-friendly vibe, the overall experience resonates with warmth and satisfaction. From the cheerful servers to the robust lineup of flavors, Rakestraw’s Ice Cream is more than a dessert stop—it’s a haven where taste buds and memories are equally delighted.

In essence, Rakestraw’s Ice Cream is where passion meets palate. It’s an inviting retreat for those seeking a perfect scoop and a slice of local history, proving that sometimes, all you need to brighten the day is a scoop of exceptional ice cream served with a smile.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Has drive-through
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Delivery
    • Dine-in
    • Same-day delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards